When you get called unfilial because you're assertive or aggressive

Kinda annoyed because I got called unfilial. Not to my face lah, but the message got to me because I kepo asked John what he and his dad talked about while I was away. And apparently it was about me being very aggressive in my pursuit of achieving my goals. I thought that was a redeeming trait? But I guess not to some people. And usually I don't give two hoots if some think of it as off putting, but this is his dad we're talking about. My father-in-law. So it bothers me to a degree even I can't seem to simply ignore.

Perhaps I am feeling a little upset because I take pride in my aggressiveness and no-nonsense attitude towards life. This attitude has enabled me to get to where I am today, and the achievements I've accomplished under my belt. I feel happy when I don't let the the naysayers provoke or hinder me, and even happier when I attain my goals despite the negativity that surrounds me. Kinda like, Aha, I proved you wrong!

So when the FIL commented that this attitude is unfilial, I feel misunderstood and under appreciated. I mean, I am STILL helping him renovate his home since the fire aftermath and am looking for agents who can sell the house for him (if they choose to sell that is, but they keep going back and forth on the decision). Do filial piety and aggressiveness not mix? 

John thinks that what his dad meant to say was that as a woman I should be more gentle and demure. But that is more like a personality problem rather than one of filial piety. I don't think I can ever pull that off as effortlessly as other females. I sometimes think even John has more femininity than I do. (Not saying he is girly, but to show how insensitive I am.) I also happen to find his dad's expectations somewhat sexist, but I guess he's one of those traditional Chinese types so I'll let it off the hook. He then mentioned that perhaps his dad also meant I should also be less vocal about my opinions (or be less opinionated, either one works) and be more considerate of his parents' feelings i.e. to listen to them more and go along with their plans/decisions more willingly even if it doesn't align with my own or my beliefs. 

This is where I am conflicted. Does being filial mean being super obedient to all the parents' requests, even if they are unreasonable or if it could hurt their own future, as long as it makes them happy? I know I sound presumptuous, but I'm sure we all know or heard of at least one parent whom you thought did more harm to themselves and/or their kids because of misguided or poor decisions. If the children of those parents choose to fight back for their parents' sake and well-being or even their own well-being, would that make them unfilial/bad children because they exude rebelliousness or a lack of consideration? And should a child always grant their parents wishes if it makes them miserable? Remember Jennifer Pan? How much do children have to sacrifice their happiness over their parents' to be considered "filial"? At what point does the scale tip, and is it never reasonable to choose your own happiness over your parents'? 

I struggle with this topic because I want to be filial--my parents raised me to view filial piety as a virtuous trait after all--but at the same time I don't if by doing so makes me miserable or if I have to somehow display less aggressiveness in character (typical reaction of an agro head, the irony). I guess the issue here is every parent have different definitions of what "filial" means. I don't think I fail at being filial towards my parents. At least they've never told me so. Last I heard, they claim they were proud of me. But now my other parent is saying that I'm not. And I'm stumped. 

Truth be told, the real issue is that I feel like I'm a disappointment to him, even though I personally think I'm pretty awesome compared to his own daughters. I cook well, clean, am studious, tall, creative, artistic, have good sense of humor, am financially savvy, takes good care of his son, and am a jack of all trades (perasan max). I also genuinely care about his and John's mom's well-being. How come being more aggressive and less demure than others is all it takes is to be "unfilial" and negate all those good qualities?

I get that this all started when I pushed back hard on the whole wedding thing that happened almost 2 years ago, when he wanted me to postpone my wedding to a date way later than whenever John's older sister decides hers should be. But at the same time, my own parents preferred for me to be married sooner so John and I could live together and be happy while saving money on rent. When both sets of parents (the in-laws vs. biological) have different beliefs and wants, which should you pick? I guess by Confucian "filial piety" I should listen to the in-laws since I'm "married into that family". But during the engagement I'm not! And to be fair, my parents' preference made me happier so of course I'll choose it too. Not to mention their support was overwhelming! And John much preferred to be married early too! So shouldn't I support future husband's decision and happiness over in-laws? 

Sigh. Does this mean I'll always be a black sheep daughter-in-law? And here I thought my mom and dad prepared me to be an awesome, independent, well-rounded, and capable wife/daughter-in-law. But that's not what the in-laws see! I guess as long as my husband appreciates me, that's more than enough.

But one can always wish things turned out differently. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hello

Wth, me? Homophobic?

Weight loss